0 clue of quality of box store metal or custom shops. I have a shop 20 mins from my house that has a 48hr turn around for orders and custom bends and cuts funky things. I have 0 clue on this topic other than that. Is it worth the extra cash for a custom shop? And if ud want to twist my arm about screws exposed or not ill listen to that as well....
Metal for roofs custom shops vs box stores
- Thread starter Bowkills
- Start date
Usually your metal shops end up being cheaper than the big box stores in the long run. Not familiar with shops up in your neck of the woods but around Dayton area Mansea metals is quite a bit cheaper than Menards. Higgins in Hillsboro is priced real close to Mansea as well.
Mickey Merrie
Junior Member
My metal roofs all come out of Ohio and not from the big box stores. I'll pay more if I have to, and I didn't pay more, to shop local!
What is the process at a custom shop? Roll metal sheets through to form the panel or piece? bake on finish before or after bend....actully custom? not buying a panel and pieces from plant x and slapping their name on it and only custom cutting and bending? I would struggle giving money to a place thats rebranding stuff u can get cheaper.... like the whole hunting flashlights sold for 120dollars but its 15 dollars on amazon.
I would say that would depend on the shop and questions worth asking them directly. I would imagine some parts are bought from other companies. We ain't talking about a custom knife here. Kinda like you making a custom fireplace. You still have to buy some materials to make it happen.
Mickey Merrie
Junior Member
If they are near by, go over to them and get a tour before you order. I have 3 roofs (rooves?) Two were put on by "Yoderbros. Inc." and one I put on my self. All 3 the materials came from a factory in Ohio. No issues with any of them!
It looks like its run like i pictured in my mind at that place. My lumber yard probly orders through them. Just trying to get brocks pizza not little caesars hot and ready.
whitetailjunky3
Junior Member
- 818
- 91
Hey now don’t be knocking the hot and ready us poor folk like that! On another note I got my metal from Carter lumber in grove. I have been impressed for the year and a half I had it. We put roof on barn at the farm we got that metal from hiltys in Berne it’s been great to.
NAC1989
Junior Member
The metal roof that was put on my house was metal that came from Mansea. My understanding from the guy that did the install was that Mansea made all the stuff from the coils of steel and at the time there wasn’t much wait time to get anything they needed to complete a job, at least that was how it was pre covid. If I remember correctly I think there was a longer wait for them to get the hidden fastener type panels because they were made at another Mansea plant that was in Kentucky or something like that.
Higgins in Hillsboro and Mansea make their panels from rolled steel. Run it through the machine to shape and cut.
If you make the trip to Higgins...you better pack an overnight. I'm 100% certain we could gather a few members and start a fire. Or, you could time it for Paint Creek. Either way, don't head this way unannounced.
Go with custom, they will cut it to the exact length you need so there is no waste.
Just don't be an idiot like my guy and cut the inch for gutter drip off
Mickey Merrie
Junior Member
I never said why I did my shed then kired the Yoderbros, Inc to do my camp and house, but once again we got things in common! Actually having worked tin while in college, I figured no big deal, even if it was 40 year ago or so. I have a Gambrel roof and figured instead of having 2 end pieces I'd just notch the end strips and cover both with then a continuous edge. What I found out was that a good grade of 100% GE Silicone in color match burgrundy can cover a multitude of sins!Just don't be an idiot like my guy and cut the inch for gutter drip off
Metals are melted, rolled and painted 45mins north of me. Ive layed block under two of these plants melt pots and watched the liquid hot magma go down the line. Then this place 30 mins or less buys it, runs the roll to shape the panel.
sold! Dont give two shits what the price difference is!
if i can swing it ill go standing seam but if not i like the top. Wife likes the other. Ill win.