Lundy
Member
- 1,312
- 141
I don't think he was saying you could shoot either in any barrel and get equal results at all.
If you have a rifled barrel and shoot a "foster" type slug, even the more modern improved versions you certainly are not getting anywhere near the capability in trajectory, accuracy or retained energy that a rifled barrel offers. Can you do it, sure you can, but why would you? It would be like have a bow capable of shooting 300FPS but hunting with a flu-flu
Conversely if you shoot a sabot slug from a smoothbore good luck hitting anything without the rifling to stabilize the projectile. I have been there done that many, many years ago.
The only reason there is to shoot non sabot slugs in a gun with a rifled barrel is cost and in that case you have decided to not use use weapon to it's potential. I would hope in that instance that the shot selections correspond to the reduced capability of the weapon.
If you have a rifled barrel and shoot a "foster" type slug, even the more modern improved versions you certainly are not getting anywhere near the capability in trajectory, accuracy or retained energy that a rifled barrel offers. Can you do it, sure you can, but why would you? It would be like have a bow capable of shooting 300FPS but hunting with a flu-flu
Conversely if you shoot a sabot slug from a smoothbore good luck hitting anything without the rifling to stabilize the projectile. I have been there done that many, many years ago.
The only reason there is to shoot non sabot slugs in a gun with a rifled barrel is cost and in that case you have decided to not use use weapon to it's potential. I would hope in that instance that the shot selections correspond to the reduced capability of the weapon.