This is an awesome topic, thanks for making this thread.
First of all, everything we do in life has inherent risk. We must except this or live in a bubble. With that being said, I will give you some history of me and hunting.
I’ve been a firefighter for 29 paid, 2 volunteer. I’ve seen a lot and dealt w more shit than I wanted to. Anyway, I know peoples perspectives are different as my age has changed mine, along with having a wife and kids.
I never liked heights. To this day I’m on alert when off the ground, so I have a lot of respect for falling or the fear of falling lol. I started wearing a harness around 23 when the deer hunting bug hit me. Yes I’ve climbed many times without one, I knew the risk I was taking. Through my career as a Ff and hunter, I have changed without making a change. Safety measures are in place to keep you most safe, most of the time or minimize a risk of having something bad happen.
Ok I’m rambling on sorry. There is measures you can take in all situations. I have changed more since my kids were born. We use climbers, lokons, ladders, portable sticks and what I call chicken sticks... the kind that lock together and go all the way to the stand. It was mentioned that most falls happen getting in a stand or out, I believe this to be corrected. Most times it’s because we are not taking advantage of a safety system.
Let me throw this out there: I’m not a professional climber or osha safety instructor.
Lifelines should always be used. Harnesses should always be used. A 6’ fall can be as traumatic as a 30’ fall.
So with all that out there I will give my opinion. At no time should you leave the ground without a safety line, once connected and off the ground, you should never disconnect till back on the ground. YouTube is your friend, so is some paracord in your pocket. I hear about suspension trauma and it is a problem, also using safety equipment wrong. I’ve had some close oh shit moments and never a situation. Let’s talk about some scenarios that can happen with each type of climbing equipment.
1. The ordinary climber, has two parts. Piece that you utilize to climb w hands and also use to sit on. The other is your platform. I use this the most for public land and portability. If you read my recent live thread I had some mishaps. My straps were in horrific condition. I used my stand in October w no issues then used it a month later and was a epic fail. How did this happen I asked my self. This is called the normalization of deviancy. Please watch the whole video. It is worth the 15 minutes of your life. I should check my stuff after every climb. The reason I didn’t is human nature.
2. The lokon is perhaps the most dangerous to me. I have been erecting them without a lineman’s belt, won’t do that anymore. I do use a safety line once it’s up and stay connected at all times.
3. Ladder stands, when thinking about it this should be one of the safest stands to climb, but they aren’t. I know of a friend that his stand collapsed trying to put one on a tree. Almost has happened to me.
4. The old build it out of wood and make the stand yourself. I don’t need to explain this one I hope.
So the common denominator with all these stands besides the inherent risks are what? Me! Cutting corners and cutting corners and cutting corners. So all my safety values have been compromised. It’s not if but when will it happen.
So before you climb again ask yourself did I prepare myself for success or failure? Is the equipment checked and changed, is that strap holding my stand on good, is it old, rotten or did a Varmit chew it almost completely threw last night. Am I using my safety equipment correct and do I have a plan of action to get me out of a possible situation.
During these times its best to have a hunt plan or boat plan and have someone in the know of my whereabouts and expected time back.
There is plenty of stuff left out here but I didn’t want to bore you. Please watch the video, it will change your perspective (because it won’t happen to me, I have safety equipment)