Welcome to TheOhioOutdoors
Wanting to join the rest of our members? Login or sign up today!
Login / Join

Deer Differences You've Observed!

In 50ish years of chasing Whitetails here in NW Penna. and Eastern Ohio, along with forays into WV and NY I have seen quite a few unique deer over the years.

How about you, yin's, y'all, you'se? Got any pictures?

I've seen Albino deer. Seen and harvested a piebald and double drop tine, seen grey, brown and nearly black deer. Seen a double throat patch, pink nosed deer, 3 legged doe with no sign of any leg bone just backward growing hair where the shoulder should have been and she had 2 fawns with her. Saw a cactus rack buck once also that looked like it had about a dozen stalagmites growing up from the bases. I've seen deer with white socks and pink hooves also.

Another feature I've seen which is unique here in NW Pa. is the distinct structural differences between the original Pa. deer that were nearly wiped out before sport hunting and the later deer stocking program of Michigan deer. The original Pa deer were smaller and stockier animals with shorter snouts, body length and leg length. The Michigan deer transplants genetic line are much longer nosed and taller, longer, heavier animals. The differences were much more common in the 1970's then today, thanks I guess to cross breeding out the pockets of Pa original animals.

I was reminded of this when I saw the picture of the dwarf deer from down by Pittsburgh which I posted below. The Pa original deer looked much more like this dwarf then the deer we see today. Though the picture is of an anomaly and not representative of the Pa original deer. You can see the feature difference I am referring to. The Pa original deer could reach, but seldom did reach 200 pounds where the Michigan deer, like the Ohio deer often do! The differences between the 2 deer in the picture are much like the differences described by me though certainly not representative of the 2 strains I'm referring to. dwarf.jpg
 
I've seen some odd ball deer, here in Ohio, but never killed any of them. :unsure:
* I seen a piebald doe running across the road with a herd of others and pretty close to where I live. Never seen her again.
* The year I was hunting with a Horse Bow, I shot and missed a basket racked 5 pointer. He looked like he'd been sleeping on his rack as it grew, as both sides were pointing the same direction. :oops: After the shot he ran across the highway and got hit. :rolleyes:
* A hunting buddy bow shot a perfectly healthy doe. Average broadside shot and she ran approximately 40ish yards. Upon field dressing the doe, his hand bumped into something hard, in the lung area. He quickly jerked his hand out and he became very cautious as he continued removing the heart/lungs. Apparently, the doe had impaled herself on a stick and it punctured her lung. The lung had collapsed and calcified around the stick. Her ribs and hide had healed and showed no signs of an injury.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mickey Merrie

ThatBuckeyeGuy

Active Member
1,329
63
Ohio
In 50ish years of chasing Whitetails here in NW Penna. and Eastern Ohio, along with forays into WV and NY I have seen quite a few unique deer over the years.

How about you, yin's, y'all, you'se? Got any pictures?

I've seen Albino deer. Seen and harvested a piebald and double drop tine, seen grey, brown and nearly black deer. Seen a double throat patch, pink nosed deer, 3 legged doe with no sign of any leg bone just backward growing hair where the shoulder should have been and she had 2 fawns with her. Saw a cactus rack buck once also that looked like it had about a dozen stalagmites growing up from the bases. I've seen deer with white socks and pink hooves also.

Another feature I've seen which is unique here in NW Pa. is the distinct structural differences between the original Pa. deer that were nearly wiped out before sport hunting and the later deer stocking program of Michigan deer. The original Pa deer were smaller and stockier animals with shorter snouts, body length and leg length. The Michigan deer transplants genetic line are much longer nosed and taller, longer, heavier animals. The differences were much more common in the 1970's then today, thanks I guess to cross breeding out the pockets of Pa original animals.

I was reminded of this when I saw the picture of the dwarf deer from down by Pittsburgh which I posted below. The Pa original deer looked much more like this dwarf then the deer we see today. Though the picture is of an anomaly and not representative of the Pa original deer. You can see the feature difference I am referring to. The Pa original deer could reach, but seldom did reach 200 pounds where the Michigan deer, like the Ohio deer often do! The differences between the 2 deer in the picture are much like the differences described by me though certainly not representative of the 2 strains I'm referring to.View attachment 192274

Man if this isn't proof your phone pays attention to everything you do. I read your post and within 2 hours this article was on my Google feed with the picture you referenced o_O

 
Man if this isn't proof your phone pays attention to everything you do. I read your post and within 2 hours this article was on my Google feed with the picture you referenced o_O

LOL. My wife and I were coming back through Indiana from out in Nebraska a couple years ago and I told her (she was driving) that I felt like I might have diarrhea and that if I told her to get me to a bathroom she had better do it quickly! Within a half hour I got an Imodium Ad sent to my phone... I had never received a text ad of any kind before that one!
 

giles

Cull buck specialist
Supporting Member
I have seen 2 different "runt" deer. Both bucks and 50 miles apart. I know one of them were killed by another hunter. Mature buck dressed out under 100 lbs. Athens County. That was in my trophy stage of hunting. That deer would come straight to the Ever Calm scent every time. Had to shoe him away. Told the hunter that one time and his wife killed him the first hunt. Couldn't tell that dickhead anything. Slimy human being.
 

Buckmaster

Senior Member
14,489
205
Portage
About 20 years ago, on our SEO property, my father while early season bow hunting passed on a weird spike buck. He described it as 15” tall straight off it skull. The antlers went up, they formed a corkscrew twisting together, than they separated, and went back up like a normal spike. We named it the Unicorn buck. No one ever saw it again. In hindsight, he wished he’d shot it for a conversation piece.