If the goal is to kill a big deer every year, I think you’d be better off buying smaller, key pieces of property. You can’t kill a big deer if he’s not here, and you better buy at least 2,000 acres if you plan to keep him all to yourself. I think smaller properties consisting of prime habitat and food would pull more deer into your wheelhouse if you played your cards right.
That being said, I’d opt for one large property… essentially a homestead. And I would buy brand new equipment and start farming. Every gallon of fuel, every individual seed I planted, and every piece of iron I purchased, would all be tax-deductible under the farm LLC. I’d never work a real job again. I’d farm, both for grain and for wildlife.