Welcome to TheOhioOutdoors
Wanting to join the rest of our members? Login or sign up today!
Login / Join

Stark County late season GIANT!!!!!!!!

giles

giles

Cull buck specialist
Supporting Member
47,290
238
The real Amish country
alphatail said:
And hicks, not in a park. A city limits area where deer are commonly watched.
Here's order of what I'm saying.
1.Deer shot. Story claims shot on x road 3-4 miles south of town.(my road)

2. Day before deer shot, hunter who killed deer had a friend who spotted and posted on fb that he saw this buck with the hunters brother in this city limit area.3-4 miles away from where it was said to be shot a day later.

3. Trail can pics came flying out of this deer just north of the main city limits area this deer has been seen at.

4. I posted to point out the obvious lie that this deer was not killed on my road. Or by it. Then added my opinion that there are fishy things about this deer. Never said he poached it. Just that the story does not make sense to the people who know this deer.
Click to expand...

Sounds like a very well planned out deer drive happened, and it worked!
 
Bigslam51

Bigslam51

Dignitary Member
Supporting Member
25,778
127
Stark County
uploadfromtaptalk1455086289215.jpguploadfromtaptalk1455086300903.jpg
 
Jackalope

Jackalope

Dignitary Member
Staff member
39,181
274
Boarhead said:
If the guy did kill it legally it is shit rumor threads like this that suck.
I feel for the guy if he did it the right way.
Click to expand...

There's an easy solution. Don't lie as say you shot it miles an miles south of where it was seen just a couple days prior. Or where it's been seen it's entire life. Sounds to me like like this deer was a solid regular in the city. Then all of a sudden it decided to up an move 4 miles through the city to an area he's never been seen at before? Durring the rut on a non urban buck I might believe that's possible. But not the last weekend of season with a deer that has does within spitting distance at his safe core area in the city. I'm not saying he did. Just saying that doesn't jive.

Whatever happened I think it's pretty obvious he lying about something. He either shot it legally and lied about, or he poached it and lied about it.
 
the Lackster

the Lackster

Junior Member
1,593
102
Georgia land of the free loaders
When I shoot a good deer I just go ahead and try to put all the possible rumors out in the air right off the bat. Shot it at night, over bait, from a truck, out of season, while free basing at my girlfriends house while my wife was at work.
 
Jackalope

Jackalope

Dignitary Member
Staff member
39,181
274
the Lackster said:
When I shoot a good deer I just go ahead and try to put all the possible rumors out in the air right off the bat. Shot it at night, over bait, from a truck, out of season, while free basing at my girlfriends house while my wife was at work.
Click to expand...

You forgot while blasting some AC/DC.
 
Jackalope

Jackalope

Dignitary Member
Staff member
39,181
274
I love how if you question anything about a deer that was killed it's labeled as "jealousy". Lol. Speaks volumes about deer hunting today. It's not a competition. Its a deer. Are we as hunters in some kind of race I wasn't aware of? It's like if someone says "how the hell did Bernie win New Hampshire last night" and someone else saying "oh quit being jealous of Bernie" lol.
 
Palmatedbuck04

Palmatedbuck04

Junior Member
39
0
Auburn twp.
Jackalope said:
I love how if you question anything about a deer that was killed it's labeled as "jealousy". Lol. Speaks volumes about deer hunting today. It's not a competition. Its a deer. Are we as hunters in some kind of race I wasn't aware of? It's like if someone says "how the hell did Bernie win New Hampshire last night" and someone else saying "oh quit being jealous of Bernie" lol.
Click to expand...

Do u have a better word to describe it??
 
Bigcountry40

Bigcountry40

Member
4,789
137
brock ratcliff said:
If Mason or I ever shoot a really good one, I'm filming the whole thing, at least recovery. That is, if I can't get a WO to tag along.

On a side note, for anyone that thinks it is unlikely a deer will move 3 miles, you are wrong. I know for a fact from trying to kill one specific deer, they think nothing of picking up and moving on a whim. Once they hunker down in an area, they will remain there for several weeks or even a month, but when they decide it is time to go...they go. There is a real chance this deer found a better brand of bird feed across town a decided to stay where he had not been seen before. Just trying to give the be nefit of the doubt here, really because I hate hearing of deer like this being taken be less than ethical means, which they often are.
Click to expand...

I read an article a few years ago about a monster killed in the Cincy area (suburban deer)that would literally travel about a mile everyday and was killed in a bean field. If I remember correctly he had like a 3 mile range as well.
 
A

alphatail

Junior Member
29
0
Yes from alliance. And that's my whole point of even posting on this thread I guess. I'm in no way jealous. Just curious as to why he would lie of shooting a deer in a location that a lot of people know he is not there.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.