I like the fit and feel of the Muck boots, but IMO they are piss-poor when it comes to durability. If you deer hunt relatively often, those neoprene sides will get chewed up and punctured very fast. I was dead set on getting a pair, then I saw my dad's 2 year old pair and now there's no way I'll ever buy them. They are only waterproof in about 6 inches of water now.
I bought a pair of the new Lacrosse Alphaburly Pro boots a couple months ago and I really like them. Light, comfortable, and much more rugged than the Mucks.