Name a time in the history when deer congregated around single sources of food/supplements/water more than they do now. I am slowly turning over on my feelings about baiting, minerals and man-made watering holes. We're encouraging deer to spend more time in close proximity and things like EHD, CWD and diseases yet to rear their ugly head are the results of multiple deer being in close contact with one another. If you look at the area around Barlow/Fleming where they are finding them, I can't think of a hunter I know in that area that doesn't bait, myself included. Whether you use it to kill deer or to get pictures, it has the same result.
The worst known EHD outbreak in Ohio history happened about 10 years ago in Meigs Co. 5 years ago, Meigs came out of obscurity to lead the state in record book entries.
Very interesting view. I could see this being a contributing factor add in social media and we know more about what people are seeing everywhere instead of just in our back yard.You fellas seem to have the impression that EHD outbreaks are on the increase. Every time I have heard a biologist speak about it, they claim it has likely always existed. I tend to believe that. What has changed are the number of people chasing deer on opening day of archery season, and the preceding scouting. I can tell you with near 100 percent certainty, the vast majority of hunters were NOT in the woods snooping around in August 20 years ago. The ones that did were very dedicated and very rare. Opening day was The first Saturday of October, and the majority of bow hunters did not even get serious until closer to Halloween. I contend we have likely had this issue intermittently forever, it just went unnoticed because no one was looking. There certainly were not folks wondering what happened to the big velvet bucks they had been getting trail cam pics of at a "miracle grow" mineral site.
Sounds about rightYou fellas seem to have the impression that EHD outbreaks are on the increase. Every time I have heard a biologist speak about it, they claim it has likely always existed. I tend to believe that. What has changed are the number of people chasing deer on opening day of archery season, and the preceding scouting. I can tell you with near 100 percent certainty, the vast majority of hunters were NOT in the woods snooping around in August 20 years ago. The ones that did were very dedicated and very rare. Opening day was The first Saturday of October, and the majority of bow hunters did not even get serious until closer to Halloween. I contend we have likely had this issue intermittently forever, it just went unnoticed because no one was looking. There certainly were not folks wondering what happened to the big velvet bucks they had been getting trail cam pics of at a "miracle grow" mineral site.
You fellas seem to have the impression that EHD outbreaks are on the increase. Every time I have heard a biologist speak about it, they claim it has likely always existed. I tend to believe that. What has changed are the number of people chasing deer on opening day of archery season, and the preceding scouting. I can tell you with near 100 percent certainty, the vast majority of hunters were NOT in the woods snooping around in August 20 years ago. The ones that did were very dedicated and very rare. Opening day was The first Saturday of October, and the majority of bow hunters did not even get serious until closer to Halloween. I contend we have likely had this issue intermittently forever, it just went unnoticed because no one was looking. There certainly were not folks wondering what happened to the big velvet bucks they had been getting trail cam pics of at a "miracle grow" mineral site.
I don't disagree, to an extent. EHD has likely been the culprit to more than a few dead deer each year. But I don't believe that because there were less people in the woods back in the day, that the body count would have went unnoticed. I would contest that more ground was covered in the state of Ohio back in the hay day when gun season was king, than is covered now. News of large quantities of dead deer would not go unnoticed. It may not have spread like the wildfire social media allows, but it would have made it's rounds.Very interesting view. I could see this being a contributing factor add in social media and we know more about what people are seeing everywhere instead of just in our back yard.
The worst known EHD outbreak in Ohio history happened about 10 years ago in Meigs Co. 5 years ago, Meigs came out of obscurity to lead the state in record book entries.
Probably brought in by insurance companies.
I use minerals as others primarily for pictures so I'm as guilty as the next and agree with others it congregates the deer herd with little benefit. Other states like it's illegal to bait and hunt over still use minerals for pictures in EHD season. Personally one thing I feel that no one mentioned is almost all minerals are 70% salt which is going to force the deer to water more often.
Great point and welcome to the forum!