Given Your Choice.....

[Fletch]

Ok.... You have two really nice bucks headed your way... Ones a perfect 12 point that is very symmetrical and the other has junk coming out everywhere... Both will score approx. the same... Which one you shooting... Junk is different and cool, but I'm taking the nice even symmetrical rack every time...

 

[Sgt Fury]

I’ll take door number two....I’ve got plenty of symmetrical bucks, never killed a true non typical.

 

[Wildlife]

Let'em walk - 'TOO' small

Seriously though, doesn't matter to me, which ever one offers up the best opportunity to take him cleanly will get the shot.

 

[5Cent]

Non typical regardless of score.

 

[giles]

I like trash...that’s why I hang with this crew.

 

[Fletch]

I’ll take door number two....I’ve got plenty of symmetrical bucks, never killed a true non typical.

Ok... So lets look whats behind doors number 1 and 2.....

First buck is behind door number 1 and second buck is behind door number 2... Buck behind door number 2 scored higher than door number 1.... I'm taking door number 1...

 

[Isaacorps]

#1 for sure

 

[Sgt Fury]

Ok... So lets look whats behind doors number 1 and 2.....

First buck is behind door number 1 and second buck is behind door number 2... Buck behind door number 2 scored higher than door number 1.... I'm taking door number 1...

That is a great typical but I’m still taking door number two. Not many people have killed a non typical....and I’m not talking about a typical with three or four abnormal points...I mean a true non typical.

 

[bowhunter1023]

I'll take mass and junk over clean any day.

 

[Hortontoter]

I'd take the non-typical every time.

 

[Iowa_Buckeye]

Am I hunting with Chris Brackett in this scenario?

 

[OhioWhiteTails]

I'm going with the junk buck, I love character on a whitetail.

 

[Dannmann801]

Which one has the bigger body/most meat?

 

[Jackalope]

Big nice clean symmetrical. Bit the NT would be hard to pass of he got there first.

 

["J"]

I wouldn’t worry about either of them getting close too me after sharting in my pants after seeing them, they’d wind me and be in the next county....

 

[hickslawns]

Are they the same age? Aw who cares. Whichever shows up first. Not many would pass either buck. I'd probably go with #2 because we don't see many NT in my area. Plenty of clean 8pt or 10pt. Not many 12pt though.

 

[cspot]

I would pick door #3 which is a 2.5 year old spike. Need to cull his genes out of the herd. LOL. I would probably take the 1st buck that gave me a clean shot.

 

[cspot]

Oh wait. I just solved it. The answer is that you are in STARK COUNTY and if you can't make up your mind then just wait for the next buck as it will be a booner too.

 

[bigten05]

Whatever one got to me first

 

[Fletch]

Oh wait. I just solved it. The answer is that you are in STARK COUNTY and if you can't make up your mind then just wait for the next buck as it will be a booner too.

Yup.... Stark County land of giants... Hell even home to a Sasquatch... Don't get any better than that...