Phil, I had an Apex sight before I bought the Axcel Armortech sight, and it was very nice. The micro adjustment on it works very well, plus it comes with a sight light. That would be my choice of the ones you had listed.
Completely disagree. Top shooters shoot high-dollar sights because they are GIVEN to them, so they can sell them to you. That's fact. No way a sight (being a 50 dollar Walmart sight, or a 250 dollar SureLoc), is going to make a difference in a hunting situation. There is not that much difference. I will agree a person may see a difference if they choose to throw their bow down from a 25 foot stand vs using a pull rope. Some are built a bit better...but I don't throw my bow on a rock from 25 feet anyway.
In case you've ever thought about going the single-pin route, here's a good deal on an HHA Optimizer... 98 bucks. Carpn shoots HHA sights and he really likes them.
http://www.lancasterarchery.com/hha-optimizer-lite-ol-5019-019-sight.html
Single pins are nice for 3D, but man I'd have a headache if I tried to use one for hunting.
Muti pin slider...Best of both worlds IMO...My new set up is a 5 pin Copper John Mark 1 with 2 pins removed mounted on a Copper John Mark 4 slider bracket with a 2nd axis kit..25,35 an 42 pins(call it weird I dont care).The the sight tape,slider an bottom pin take over from there...Yea, I don't know. I've always thought the same thing, but Jake says it's really not a hinderance while hunting. I guess it all depends on your setups... If you're consistently setting stands within 30 yds of trails, I bet you could get away with using only one pin.
Muti pin slider...Best of both worlds IMO...My new set up is a 5 pin Copper John Mark 1 with 2 pins removed mounted on a Copper John Mark 4 slider bracket with a 2nd axis kit..25,35 an 42 pins(call it weird I dont care).The the sight tape,slider an bottom pin take over from there...
We have similar set ups really,moving the slider is for off season longer range shooting..Like you I have my 3 pins set,on foam I am in the vitals from 10-15 out to 45 yrds with those 3 pins an my arrows trajectory using those pin setting ..50yrds I would do the same as you,not move the slider but hold high(about 8 or 9inches above my intended poi )..The slider part is just for longer range off season shooting an wont get moved while in the woods.That way I can keep the same setup most of the year.My 25pin puts me at just under 2in high at 15yrd an about 2.5inch low at 30yrds..My 35yrd pin shoots just over 2.5 high at 30/31yrds an just over 2.5 low at 39 yrds.. ..At 40yrds an beyond the 42 pin takes over put me about dead even at 40 an about 3inch low at 45yrd...Really I only wanna use the first 2 pins in the woods because my judging gets dicey past 35 or so yards an I dont use a range finder .Plus only using the 2 pins I could simply decide if its over 30 or under 30 an then pick the appropriate pin.It sounds complicated but its really not.. .I did it this way because I have missed 2 deer due to misjudgement...I'd get screwed up in the heat of the moment and still use the wrong pin. That or I would spend too long hem-hawing around pinking a yardage and the deer would have passed through my shooting lane. I keep it simple; Three pins 20, 30, 40, and I can hold on the top of the back for 50 and take out the lungs, if needed.
I have missed some deer. Tree limbs a couple times, and I rushed one shot. Clean misses each time. I have a range finder and i use it. I am going to keep it simple because I have killed me some deer and I hope to kill me some more I know what works for me. Five pin sight 30-40-50-60-70 or 25-35-45-55-65 or whatever it ends up being. When the moment of truth arrives, my thoughts are going to be on my form, my breathing, my pin, and the spot on the deer I picked out to aim at. I am not as seasoned as many of these guys, but I know enough to use the KSS rule. That will have to work for me. Thanks for sharing though Nick. Just sounds too confusing for hunting. 3D? Maybe. Hunting?