The Johnny King Buck

[hickslawns]

Thanks for sharing this article Mike. I have a P&Y buck. My next goal would be OBBC. The actions of B&C make me think whether I would ever want to register one with them. Might never happen for me anyway, but if it does, I will think long and hard before registering it.

 

[finelyshedded]

Very interesting article Mike. Thanks for sharing that. To read that the only factor the B&C is hanging their decision on is the length difference of the two G2 tines in question is beyond absurd! They want perfection that bad! Good grief!

It's also interesting about why P&Y is jumping in on this witch hunt! Are they in bed with B&C? The James Jordan deer possibly getting unseated as Wiskys número UNO typical record! Scorers within the Wisconsin. Buck & Bear club not wanting to jeopardize their chances to become B&C official scorers! There are motives and conspiracies galore.

Just sad that this deer isn't getting the credit it's due! 180 nontypical hahaha

 

[Schu72]

Just for a comparison take a look at the second photo on this link. The common base points on the lloyd Goad buck were ruled "typical".

http://www.archerytalk.com/vb/showthread.php?t=1584611


Here's another giant, the Sam Collora buck, that P&Y ruled 2 points on the left antler "non-typical" and dropped the original score from 204 to 193.

http://www.buckmasters.com/big-buck-central/btr/btr_photo_gallery.aspx?sid=2527

 

[finelyshedded]

IMO, I always saw the Sam Collora(Mrs. doe pee buck) as having abnormal points. The ones on the right side are not on top of the mb and more to the outside or not in line. The left side is typical.

The Goad deer is atypical as is the King deer. No difference! It goes to show you how inconsistent the B&C org. has become. The g2's look just as different as far as their length.

 

[JD Boyd]

Boone-Crockett announced they will panel score it...

 

[xbowguy]

Good Deal! Glad to see justice instead of one guy saying no.

 

[JD Boyd]

Big article about it on deer&deer hunting web site... We shall see...lol

 

[customizer1000]

I think they should score the deer how the deer is, no deductions, just an overall score

 

[Jackalope]

Question is will it still be fair. They've already intimidated their scores by making it known they're serious about this deer not making it.

 

[customizer1000]

I think Hanson has something on them, they won't let it get beat even if its a record deer

 

[JD Boyd]

Question is will it still be fair. They've already intimidated their scores by making it known they're serious about this deer not making it.

I don't think they have any other choice...

 

[bowhunter1023]

There's an ego or 50 in there somewhere that will screw this guy again IMO. But at least it'll get some time in the spotlight in a positive manner...

 

[finelyshedded]

I'll be interested in how this plays out.

 

[JD Boyd]

B-C made there decision... 180 inch typical if he wants it that way or 217 non typ... This should put all the controversy over it to rest... Finally!!!

 

[customizer1000]

37" of deductions? Wth

 

[Jackalope]

Like we didn't know they would screw him. They've already intimidated their scoters into compliance.

 

[customizer1000]

No shit Hanson has dirt on them, they won't let the title switch

 

[JD Boyd]

Two scorers hadn't even heard of the buck... Who got screwed? The buyer??? He's the only one. Who knows what he paid for a 180 inch typ that ranks around #950 in the all time records...lol... He's an idiot... Why can a dumb ass like me tell its a non typ point???

 

[customizer1000]

Two scorers hadn't even heard of the buck... Who got screwed? The buyer??? He's the only one. Who knows what he paid for a 180 inch typ that ranks around #950 in the all time records...lol... He's an idiot... Why can a dumb ass like me tell its a non typ point???

Cause jd your a Dumbass with good eyes lol jk

 

[Monster Raxx]

Did the two scorers wake up from a comma? How the hell did they not hear about this buck?