You do realize the best teams in November and December weren't always the best In September. College football is ruled by recruiting. It's just a cycle. The top 2-3 teams always make it. Then the top top players go to said teams. Rinse and repeat. What all the Bamas, OSU's, and Clemsons dont want is other teams getting a chance at playoffs which would in turn give them a bump in recruiting. I've followed recruiting intently for 25 years, I understand the dynamics involved with winning and prestige and how it correlates to recruiting success, which results in success on the field. You dont like the playoffs? Do you not enjoy March Madness?
Not really...I don't like basketball to begin with, but the dynamics of the sport are different. The demands put on the players are different. You can play 30 basketball games per season. You can't do that with football.
I'm a conservative. I don't believe in changing anything unless its broken. The BCS worked just fine for selecting the #1 and #2 teams in the nation and pitting them for the national championship. But we gave in to the playoff hucksters and expanded that to four. But that's not good enough....when will it be?
When we allow the top two teams frm every conference in?
I understand that winning breeds winners. And that kids will flock to play for the team that gives them the best chance to get to the NFL. Right now, those teams are Bama, OSU, and Clemson. Twenty five years ago those teams were Florida, Florida State, Miami and Nebraska. Where are those teams now?
All its going to take to break the deadlock at the top is for Saban to retire. He will likely be replaced by Smart and UGA. There is no need to upend the entire system just because some teams want to luck into the playoffs now. Also, there will be no end to the whining. If you expand the playoffs to six teams then the seventh will whine and cry and throw tantrums. Expand it to 8 and the 9th team will whine and cry. And nothing will change. Bama, OSU, and Clemson will still whip all their asses in the playoffs anyway.