Yeah I agree to a certain point. However..if a mature buck based his travel habits soley on wind direction he would be walking in circles in the hill country of SE Ohio. Just because there is a west wind doesn't mean wind will be blowing west in the hills and hollows. West winds coming accross SE Ohio end up turbulent and swirl in every direction.
Wind direction really doesn't dictate when I hunt or where I hunt..if it did..I would end up having very few days of the season to hunt.
One time in 34 years of deer hunting, I encountered a deer that “had” to go through one of 2 pinch points to get from where he was to where he wanted to be…and he was a 180,” 7.5+ year old buck that my son killed the last week of the 2009 bow season.
We had wireless trail cameras set up at the head of both pinch points. The following graph represents 40+ initial photos over an 8 week period. The ridge ran east and west. The deer could only approach my sons set up(s) from the west. I have no idea how he got back to his bedding cover as we never had a single encounter or photo in the morning or headed in the opposite direction. The red line represents the first photo taken when the wind direction had included anything with a “W.” The blue line was the first photo where the wind included any kind of “E.” The “Y” axis is military time.
Even under the cover of darkness, this SOB moved an average of 2 hours later when the wind was at his back…again,
in the dark!
This buck had a system and it worked really well for a really long time. He was probably the most well known deer in Athens County History as his summer range included an urban field just off a 4 lane highway. His fall and winter range was accessible from public hunting ground but not easily. There was no way to press him undetected.